By reviewing my peers’ papers, I learned that a variety of ideas are needed to present a complete paper. I found many points of view presented in my peers’ paper. This made me aware that I should consider several positions. Reading their showed that I should be more conscious of what is occurring in my intended field. It seems as though my fellow peers know much about the subjects they are writing. They may have read a good number of sources. Some topics were of no interest to me, whatsoever, which made it difficult to read. If my writing happens to be of no interest to others, then I need to present my material in a way that sparks interest. I’ve discovered that I need more sources.
Monday, November 22, 2010
Monday, November 15, 2010
Weekly Writing #9
The readings from the Introduction to Graduate Studies Course fit into my course plan by giving me examples of scholarly writing. Two articles in particular, “Disaster Preparedness Information Needs of Individuals Attending an Adult Literacy Center” and “Ties that Bind: Cultural Referent Groups and Coping Strategies of Adult Women as Learners” are direct tie-ins to the field I want to enter, which is Adult Basic Education. Since reading near the beginning of this course, I have been exposed to many other helpful articles in the Adult Education Arena.
The research for the project in this class has been helpful because it gives me the ability to focus specifically on current trends in Adult Education as I build future research projects around the field of study. Upcoming courses in my plan mostly center on exposure to a variety of literature and on writing, which is where I can use the most help. At this time, I will not make any adjustment to my plan. The only changes I may make in the future will occur if a wider variety of courses are offered on this campus. I do need more information on the behind-the-scenes issues of Adult Basic Education, such as obtaining certification to administer and score the TABE test, which is the precursor to GED study and to the GED exam.
I especially find this course helpful when Dr. McCracken discusses and advises about the comprehensive examination. We have been advised that we will need three professors in our area of study on for the exam and for our thesis committees. It must be composed of a committee chair, from USF and two additional doctorate-level scholars. While keeping thoughts in my mind, I plan to take a serious look at the exams immediately following my Spring 2011 semester. If possible, I would like to focus on the development of a stellar adult education program that will spur GED students on towards collegiate coursework. I have written to one person that I would like to work with, Dr. Debby Vanderwoude, the principle of Tomlinson Adult Learning Center, asking whether she is interested on being on my committee. I met her when I completed a service learning project there earlier this yet. So far, I have not received a response. I would also like to potentially work with Dr. Starks-Estes as the MLA program-head and Dr. Leung, since my focus in this MLA track is English.
Based on what I’ve learned in class tonight, the readings that I accumulate over upcoming semesters will be the basis for my comprehensive examination questions. The questions will be given to me in a closed classroom setting where I will be expected to write freely, with no tools, answering questions. Fortunately, I have also done this at Eckerd College as a timed-writing (with no notes) and as part of their comprehensive exams (with one page notes). I’m sure this will be more challenging at the graduate-school level.
Saturday, October 23, 2010
Weekly Writing #8
Weekly Writing #8
As a research project, I would like to explore the level of availability of Associates or Bachelor’s degrees to students who have Adult Basic Education backgrounds. Improving the propensity for previous ABE students to earn their degrees is my primary goal. Assisting colleges in working with the students is also a desire.
As a research project, I would like to explore the level of availability of Associates or Bachelor’s degrees to students who have Adult Basic Education backgrounds. Improving the propensity for previous ABE students to earn their degrees is my primary goal. Assisting colleges in working with the students is also a desire.
Right now, my plan is to define ABE requirements, examine the propensity for students who attain high school equivalency diplomas through this process, to complete undergraduate degrees. I can research data that has been collected and limit my results to Pinellas County or St. Petersburg. I can also share technique that others in this field have found to increase the numbers, what is helpful to students, what works or does not work. This matter is of societal concern because in many cases, education improves the lives of individuals and if within individuals, perhaps in their communities and in society overall.
I feel hopeful about my research project. I believe data will be available to me through journal and newspaper articles and by direct contact with such graduates and professors. I have not advanced as far into my research as I hoped by now, but I plan to devote more time to it. I have identified a number of articles and have been storing them in Refworks for later review.
I have created a Google Alert which e-mails daily information about my topic. I recommend this step to anyone wanting to locate recent discussions about their topic.
I could benefit from locating and interviewing students who currently possess either AA or BA degrees and who come from ABE backgrounds. Questioning college instructors about these students would also help. I recently posed a few informal questions to a coworker who teaches a college course.
At this time, I have no specific questions. The best way to help me is to critique my work unreservedly during peer and to e-mail (afgodwin@mail.usf.edu) or print and pass along articles anyone comes across during their own research.
Thursday, October 14, 2010
Weekly Writing #7
Weekly Writing #7
Asking the Right Questions: Ch 13 & 14
Chapter 13 discusses strengthening arguments by excluding questions which form dichotomies. It provides good examples on accomplishing this. Also explained is the practicality of using If-clauses. Chapter 13 was confusing to me until I drew a line through extraneous words. Then I reread only the words which mattered and understood better. I initially thought the chapter asked us not to limit conclusion in our papers, but this made no sense. Papers should have a strong final conclusion. I discovered that what it actually does is ask writers to explore several conclusions during the research process and pick the best one. This advice: “One clever way to weaken strong reasoning is the make the claim that experts disagree” (163) is useful. It addresses a problem that I expect, though I have not yet discovered it as I am not very far along into my writing.
While reading Chapter 13, I scrutinized my own research question. The original question I planned to answer is: “What is the propensity for students from an ABE background to successfully complete post-secondary education degrees?” If I stick with this query, my paper will simply inform but will not be very compelling. The examples in the text seem to pertain best to controversial questions. I discovered that my question is not controversial enough.
Based upon the original question, I can ask: “Is there more than one possible answer?” The answer is no. My original question only allows for a dichotomy. Browne & Keeley advise the use of “why, when & where” questions to help writers discover more conclusions. On that note, I can ask: How many students from ABE backgrounds go on to attend and graduate from college?” Then I can ask “Why is the amount of students the number that it is?” “When did the number of students increase or decrease?” and “Where are the regions that send ABE graduates to college?” These are just possible examples of how I can (and may) expand my original question. I can look for patterns in the answers.
Another word of instruction in chapter 13 is when your question ceases to be a dichotomy, work on finding a variety of possible answers. Next look at the answers derived from the revised question and accept the one that is sensible to you. In the event that you acquire some or most but not all the data you can, use the “if-clause” (if/then) to show the audience that you possess only limited knowledge of the subject. I think this shows honesty and enhances the writer’s credibility. There may be more data out there.
If I ask: “How many students from ABE backgrounds go on to attend and graduate from college?” and in the resulting research I find that the number of students who do so is insignificant, I can again revise my research question and change it to: “How can students from an ABE background successfully complete a post-secondary education degree?” Then I can research not only the propensity but the challenges and propose solutions to increase the number of students. This would be more interesting and has the potential to positively contribute to my field.
Although I have experience as an individual who attended high school for twelve years but failed to graduate (fell short .5 credits due to pregnancy) but obtained a GED two years later and who did not go to college directly following high school, Chapter 14 states that I should not rely on my personal experience as the basis for my conclusion. The authors of Asking the Right Questions state, “Because we wish certain conclusions to be true, we may reason as if they are true, despite strong evidence to the contrary” (Browne & Keeley, 169). In relation to my own research, I may wish to instill hope by suggesting that non-traditional college students succeed in college, when the fact of the matter may turn out to be that they do not. I must be careful not to project my own desires onto my project.
The danger of stereotyping is mentioned. Many who attend ABE classes are wrongly categorized. I would like to contribute by adding to the work that wipes out such assumptions. However, I too would be guilty of stereotyping if I approach the subject in a way that supposes that there is truth to such statements. Also discussed is to “never permit ourselves to be so sure of anything that we stop searching for an improved version” (Browne & Keeley, 172). I do not know yet what my research may turn up; whether it is good or bad news from my perspective. This goes along with the earlier class discussion on changing ones mind after discovering that one’s argument has been disproved during research. These two chapters warn us to be responsible researching beginning with the very questions we ask. It is possible that if we enter into a project with our minds made up, we could very well find the answers we have already predetermined in our minds. This would be irresponsible and untrue to our chosen fields.
Asking the Right Questions: Ch 13 & 14
Chapter 13 discusses strengthening arguments by excluding questions which form dichotomies. It provides good examples on accomplishing this. Also explained is the practicality of using If-clauses. Chapter 13 was confusing to me until I drew a line through extraneous words. Then I reread only the words which mattered and understood better. I initially thought the chapter asked us not to limit conclusion in our papers, but this made no sense. Papers should have a strong final conclusion. I discovered that what it actually does is ask writers to explore several conclusions during the research process and pick the best one. This advice: “One clever way to weaken strong reasoning is the make the claim that experts disagree” (163) is useful. It addresses a problem that I expect, though I have not yet discovered it as I am not very far along into my writing.
While reading Chapter 13, I scrutinized my own research question. The original question I planned to answer is: “What is the propensity for students from an ABE background to successfully complete post-secondary education degrees?” If I stick with this query, my paper will simply inform but will not be very compelling. The examples in the text seem to pertain best to controversial questions. I discovered that my question is not controversial enough.
Based upon the original question, I can ask: “Is there more than one possible answer?” The answer is no. My original question only allows for a dichotomy. Browne & Keeley advise the use of “why, when & where” questions to help writers discover more conclusions. On that note, I can ask: How many students from ABE backgrounds go on to attend and graduate from college?” Then I can ask “Why is the amount of students the number that it is?” “When did the number of students increase or decrease?” and “Where are the regions that send ABE graduates to college?” These are just possible examples of how I can (and may) expand my original question. I can look for patterns in the answers.
Another word of instruction in chapter 13 is when your question ceases to be a dichotomy, work on finding a variety of possible answers. Next look at the answers derived from the revised question and accept the one that is sensible to you. In the event that you acquire some or most but not all the data you can, use the “if-clause” (if/then) to show the audience that you possess only limited knowledge of the subject. I think this shows honesty and enhances the writer’s credibility. There may be more data out there.
If I ask: “How many students from ABE backgrounds go on to attend and graduate from college?” and in the resulting research I find that the number of students who do so is insignificant, I can again revise my research question and change it to: “How can students from an ABE background successfully complete a post-secondary education degree?” Then I can research not only the propensity but the challenges and propose solutions to increase the number of students. This would be more interesting and has the potential to positively contribute to my field.
- If I found that:
- The number of students who go on to college is low
- I could ask:
- What can be done to increase the number
- The number is average
- What can be done to increase the number
- The number is high
- What is the reason for this success
- Is there something to be learned that can be applied towards traditional or non-traditional students
Although I have experience as an individual who attended high school for twelve years but failed to graduate (fell short .5 credits due to pregnancy) but obtained a GED two years later and who did not go to college directly following high school, Chapter 14 states that I should not rely on my personal experience as the basis for my conclusion. The authors of Asking the Right Questions state, “Because we wish certain conclusions to be true, we may reason as if they are true, despite strong evidence to the contrary” (Browne & Keeley, 169). In relation to my own research, I may wish to instill hope by suggesting that non-traditional college students succeed in college, when the fact of the matter may turn out to be that they do not. I must be careful not to project my own desires onto my project.
The danger of stereotyping is mentioned. Many who attend ABE classes are wrongly categorized. I would like to contribute by adding to the work that wipes out such assumptions. However, I too would be guilty of stereotyping if I approach the subject in a way that supposes that there is truth to such statements. Also discussed is to “never permit ourselves to be so sure of anything that we stop searching for an improved version” (Browne & Keeley, 172). I do not know yet what my research may turn up; whether it is good or bad news from my perspective. This goes along with the earlier class discussion on changing ones mind after discovering that one’s argument has been disproved during research. These two chapters warn us to be responsible researching beginning with the very questions we ask. It is possible that if we enter into a project with our minds made up, we could very well find the answers we have already predetermined in our minds. This would be irresponsible and untrue to our chosen fields.
Tuesday, October 12, 2010
Weekly Writing #6
PROPOSED RESEARCH PROJECT - OPTION A:
Adult literacy programs are an important factor in American society. Without them, scores of individuals from a variety of backgrounds would be unable to achieve educational goals. A great deal of attention is paid to high school students going directly to college, but is anyone interested in discovering the potential for students from Adult Basic Education backgrounds? I would like to research the likelihood of ABE students to transition to and successfully complete postsecondary education.
My questions are as follows: What is the propensity for late learners to obtain a Bachelor’s degree? Would a recruitment effort geared towards these students prove beneficial for the students and the institution? What are the basic requirements for a Bachelors degree?
I plan to enter the field of adult basic education. I am interested working with my future colleagues in filling a niche: a source of scholars for institutions and schools willing to work with these specialized learners.
I located a number of Community Programs which are advertising free adult literacy classes. Others are blogging about Global adult literacy programs.
Starting with the A’s I picked the first 14 journals which I believe may contain articles concerning the field of adult education:
1. Adult basic ed – developments in adult ed
2. Adult ed quarterly – developments in adult ed
3. Adult learning – developments in adult & post secondary ed
4. American education – developments in ed
5. Am ed research journal – data/statistics on adult ed
6. Am educator – developments in ed
7. Am journal of ed – developments in ed
8. Am school & university - developments in post secondary ed
9. Am teacher – developments in ed
10. Anthro & ed quarterly – developments in ed
11. Applied measurement in ed – data/statistics on adult ed
12. Arts & humanities in higher ed - developments in post secondary ed
13. ASHE-ERIC higher ed reports – data/statistics on adult ed
14. ASHE higher ed report – data/statistics on adult ed
I hope these journals can provide information on new trends in adult education and post secondary education as well as data and statistics on adult education.
My plan of action is as follows:
• Review journals for relevant material:10/4-10/9
• critically analyze & annotate articles: 10/11-10/16
• select quotes and statistics:10/18-10/23
• begin arranging data: 10/25-10/30
• prepare a draft and run it by Dr. McCracken: 11/1-11/6
Questions I have are: How much detail is required? Are we explaining our process?
Adult literacy programs are an important factor in American society. Without them, scores of individuals from a variety of backgrounds would be unable to achieve educational goals. A great deal of attention is paid to high school students going directly to college, but is anyone interested in discovering the potential for students from Adult Basic Education backgrounds? I would like to research the likelihood of ABE students to transition to and successfully complete postsecondary education.
My questions are as follows: What is the propensity for late learners to obtain a Bachelor’s degree? Would a recruitment effort geared towards these students prove beneficial for the students and the institution? What are the basic requirements for a Bachelors degree?
I plan to enter the field of adult basic education. I am interested working with my future colleagues in filling a niche: a source of scholars for institutions and schools willing to work with these specialized learners.
I located a number of Community Programs which are advertising free adult literacy classes. Others are blogging about Global adult literacy programs.
Starting with the A’s I picked the first 14 journals which I believe may contain articles concerning the field of adult education:
1. Adult basic ed – developments in adult ed
2. Adult ed quarterly – developments in adult ed
3. Adult learning – developments in adult & post secondary ed
4. American education – developments in ed
5. Am ed research journal – data/statistics on adult ed
6. Am educator – developments in ed
7. Am journal of ed – developments in ed
8. Am school & university - developments in post secondary ed
9. Am teacher – developments in ed
10. Anthro & ed quarterly – developments in ed
11. Applied measurement in ed – data/statistics on adult ed
12. Arts & humanities in higher ed - developments in post secondary ed
13. ASHE-ERIC higher ed reports – data/statistics on adult ed
14. ASHE higher ed report – data/statistics on adult ed
I hope these journals can provide information on new trends in adult education and post secondary education as well as data and statistics on adult education.
My plan of action is as follows:
• Review journals for relevant material:10/4-10/9
• critically analyze & annotate articles: 10/11-10/16
• select quotes and statistics:10/18-10/23
• begin arranging data: 10/25-10/30
• prepare a draft and run it by Dr. McCracken: 11/1-11/6
Questions I have are: How much detail is required? Are we explaining our process?
Saturday, September 25, 2010
Weekly Writing #5
Weekly Writing 5A – Dr. McCracken’s article
Dr. McCracken’s article, Street Sex Work: Re/Constructing Discourse from Margin to Center was an extremely engaging article. She offers a number of suggestions, including how the media could make changes to the rhetoric used in discussing this population. Dr. McCracken begins by defining the term ‘sex work’. This brought to mind a desire to see a future comparison from some source of the implications of ‘street sex work’ in places where it is illegal to locations like Las Vegas where the same activity is carried out legally.
Dr. McCracken refers to the ‘spirits’ of women who prostitute which made me wonder about the presence of drugs in the systems of the women. “Can sex work be tolerated without the presence of mind-altering drugs?” and “Is a woman’s spirit discernable in a drug-dependent mind?” Concerning journalists, like many, I think their main goal is to sell newspapers but the end up influencing readers while doing so. With regards to Dr. McCracken’s opening paragraphs, I would be interested in knowing why she took the amount of time taken to explain her intentions. I want to know if the same level of detail is expected or required of some of us unpublished research reporters.
I was impressed by Dr. McCracken’s use of the quote by Barry Brummett which I took to mean that the general readership does not typically know that they are targeted for persuasion. As a result, some neglect to put significant thought into exploring the basis of these presented views. Essentially, the words of many journalists, as proved in part by McCracken’s research have increased the public’s hatred of women who prostitute. Some folks are happy when they hear of arrests. Where does blame lie in reference to the male consumers?
(She said don't do this but) I loved the way Dr. McCracken broke down the number and content of articles used. One suggestion I would make is for Table 2 to have clearer delineation. I lost track while following who said what. Her paragraph, Who Gets to Speak? caused me to question, which is a better way to help women who prostitute? (At the moment, I’m not looking into the male consumers.) Is it by punishment or by diverting, teaching, and/or rehabilitating?
With regards to the voices of the women being inadequately heard, I wonder, “How many women would speak if given the chance?” Are they willing or not willing because of what they are living through? Do we know if journalists tried to ask them? If the writer did, should they include in their article, “The individual was asked but replied ‘no comment’”. Would the readership care?
One positive use for the women’s point of view would be if they had the opportunity to journal, create art, and write stories and poetry. Perhaps some already are or were artists in former lives? But what if their creations were shared with the caring portion of the public? What insight we could have and what help we could offer to them!
On page 6, in the first full paragraph, I would like to have seen Dr. McCracken soften and say, “three are deceased.” or “three were murdered” instead of “three are dead”. However, I am aware that she was advised to “make arguments and examples stronger” (15). Now this statement may or may not be a result of that, this is just my personal preference.
The last paragraph on page 9 makes an enormously strong case. Dr. McCracken goes on to discuss descriptions of the women’s skin and sadly, it seems to be just the type of material most of the public enjoys reading. The portrayal of their skin ailments is written like part of a descriptive novel. As to the reluctance to call the male consumers to task, that sort of thing has been happening for centuries. There is a story in the Bible about the woman who was caught committing adultery (John 8:1-11). The Pharisees brought her to Jesus so that He could let her have it, but nobody brought or blamed the man!
_____________________________________
Weekly Writing 5B – Disaster Preparedness article
The article, Disaster Preparedness Information Needs of Individuals Attending an Adult Literacy Center: An Exploratory Study by Daniela B. Friedman, Manju Tanwar, Deborah W. Yoho and V.E. Richter brought back memories of the period when I worked with an Adult Literacy program. This is why I chose this article. The article contains incredibly valid concerns; however, I felt that the individuals involved were portrayed as being feebler than they are.
I have to keep in mind that this is research, which means that the information reported is from the author’s findings. I think it should have been more strongly noted that people with insufficient literacy find ways to function in society. In a way, I suppose that would work against the purpose of the article.
One step towards disaster preparedness that I have noticed recently is the number of pictures of hand washing and directives to cough into the crook of one’s arm to avoid the spread of germs. It seems like I’m noticing pictures everywhere. Then the more I think of it, I’ve noticed it mostly in restaurants. So the question becomes, if the illiterate person is impoverished, are they exposed to these new symbols?
There are laymen’s (privately-owned) websites about survival which are not written in technical terms. The fact that this information is available on the internet brings me to my experience as a volunteer in adult literacy. When I volunteered with the literacy council, there is a wealth of knowledge held by people who are barely literate. The article states that the mean age was 53.1. That fact alone shows that many of these individuals have lived and survived for over five decades. That they are attending a literacy program illustrates that these individuals have reached the point in life to seek self-actualization.
On page 70, the writers state, “many did not know how to use the computers located at the literacy center”, however I did not see any proof in the paper that the participants were not computer literate. Any good literacy center includes computer instruction in their curriculum. The attendees are usually eager to learn. Attendance is usually voluntary; and believe me, the students don’t show up every day to NOT learn. Literacy centers usually have self-tutorial software and volunteers or staff who provides one-on-one instruction. The main problems are typing skills and spelling. At the center where I volunteered, the participants, many of them older people, knew how to navigate the cursor using the mouse. The lack of reading produces an inability to spell. Without knowledge of home row keys and other typing skills, participants may be slow in the mechanics of looking up information but in no way hindered from trying.
As an example, I tutored a middle-aged man for one year. He read very little, but knew how to use the computer. He also said he had a computer at home. When he was first placed on the computer during our session, he already knew how to connect it, turn it on, use the mouse and click on what he needed. He and others took placement tests using the computer. Granted, the adult literacy center in St. Petersburg may be more sophisticated than the one in South Carolina, but I think in 2010, not using or teaching computer use at these locations is behind the times.
My final thought is that I agree with the article’s premise that the government should regulate the dissemination of disaster materials. Many people with low-literacy get by with the help of friends and family. Some literacy programs provide instruction on life skills. Everything we read together was an opportunity to teach. If, for example, we read a story about a house fire, we were instructed to discuss actions in the event that they experienced a house fire. During hurricane season we discuss preparedness. When a major new story broadcasts, it is discussed. Many literate people will automatically check on the well-being of those in their own friends/family circle.
Concerning my research at this point in the semester:
I have learned what research is and how the proper use of rhetoric can make my arguments more convincing. I also know what I want to discuss which would concern some aspect of adult education and/or literacy. At this point I need to better formulate and explore one of the questions I am interested in answering. In addition, I should locate scholarly journals that deal with my subject matter. Thanks to our session at the library last week (and the introduction to RefWorks), this should go smoothly. The key will then be to find articles which support my stance (reading = time consuming) and will require me to relocate to a quiet area where I can concentrate and begin to build my paper.
Dr. McCracken’s article, Street Sex Work: Re/Constructing Discourse from Margin to Center was an extremely engaging article. She offers a number of suggestions, including how the media could make changes to the rhetoric used in discussing this population. Dr. McCracken begins by defining the term ‘sex work’. This brought to mind a desire to see a future comparison from some source of the implications of ‘street sex work’ in places where it is illegal to locations like Las Vegas where the same activity is carried out legally.
Dr. McCracken refers to the ‘spirits’ of women who prostitute which made me wonder about the presence of drugs in the systems of the women. “Can sex work be tolerated without the presence of mind-altering drugs?” and “Is a woman’s spirit discernable in a drug-dependent mind?” Concerning journalists, like many, I think their main goal is to sell newspapers but the end up influencing readers while doing so. With regards to Dr. McCracken’s opening paragraphs, I would be interested in knowing why she took the amount of time taken to explain her intentions. I want to know if the same level of detail is expected or required of some of us unpublished research reporters.
I was impressed by Dr. McCracken’s use of the quote by Barry Brummett which I took to mean that the general readership does not typically know that they are targeted for persuasion. As a result, some neglect to put significant thought into exploring the basis of these presented views. Essentially, the words of many journalists, as proved in part by McCracken’s research have increased the public’s hatred of women who prostitute. Some folks are happy when they hear of arrests. Where does blame lie in reference to the male consumers?
(She said don't do this but) I loved the way Dr. McCracken broke down the number and content of articles used. One suggestion I would make is for Table 2 to have clearer delineation. I lost track while following who said what. Her paragraph, Who Gets to Speak? caused me to question, which is a better way to help women who prostitute? (At the moment, I’m not looking into the male consumers.) Is it by punishment or by diverting, teaching, and/or rehabilitating?
With regards to the voices of the women being inadequately heard, I wonder, “How many women would speak if given the chance?” Are they willing or not willing because of what they are living through? Do we know if journalists tried to ask them? If the writer did, should they include in their article, “The individual was asked but replied ‘no comment’”. Would the readership care?
One positive use for the women’s point of view would be if they had the opportunity to journal, create art, and write stories and poetry. Perhaps some already are or were artists in former lives? But what if their creations were shared with the caring portion of the public? What insight we could have and what help we could offer to them!
On page 6, in the first full paragraph, I would like to have seen Dr. McCracken soften and say, “three are deceased.” or “three were murdered” instead of “three are dead”. However, I am aware that she was advised to “make arguments and examples stronger” (15). Now this statement may or may not be a result of that, this is just my personal preference.
The last paragraph on page 9 makes an enormously strong case. Dr. McCracken goes on to discuss descriptions of the women’s skin and sadly, it seems to be just the type of material most of the public enjoys reading. The portrayal of their skin ailments is written like part of a descriptive novel. As to the reluctance to call the male consumers to task, that sort of thing has been happening for centuries. There is a story in the Bible about the woman who was caught committing adultery (John 8:1-11). The Pharisees brought her to Jesus so that He could let her have it, but nobody brought or blamed the man!
_____________________________________
Weekly Writing 5B – Disaster Preparedness article
The article, Disaster Preparedness Information Needs of Individuals Attending an Adult Literacy Center: An Exploratory Study by Daniela B. Friedman, Manju Tanwar, Deborah W. Yoho and V.E. Richter brought back memories of the period when I worked with an Adult Literacy program. This is why I chose this article. The article contains incredibly valid concerns; however, I felt that the individuals involved were portrayed as being feebler than they are.
I have to keep in mind that this is research, which means that the information reported is from the author’s findings. I think it should have been more strongly noted that people with insufficient literacy find ways to function in society. In a way, I suppose that would work against the purpose of the article.
One step towards disaster preparedness that I have noticed recently is the number of pictures of hand washing and directives to cough into the crook of one’s arm to avoid the spread of germs. It seems like I’m noticing pictures everywhere. Then the more I think of it, I’ve noticed it mostly in restaurants. So the question becomes, if the illiterate person is impoverished, are they exposed to these new symbols?
There are laymen’s (privately-owned) websites about survival which are not written in technical terms. The fact that this information is available on the internet brings me to my experience as a volunteer in adult literacy. When I volunteered with the literacy council, there is a wealth of knowledge held by people who are barely literate. The article states that the mean age was 53.1. That fact alone shows that many of these individuals have lived and survived for over five decades. That they are attending a literacy program illustrates that these individuals have reached the point in life to seek self-actualization.
On page 70, the writers state, “many did not know how to use the computers located at the literacy center”, however I did not see any proof in the paper that the participants were not computer literate. Any good literacy center includes computer instruction in their curriculum. The attendees are usually eager to learn. Attendance is usually voluntary; and believe me, the students don’t show up every day to NOT learn. Literacy centers usually have self-tutorial software and volunteers or staff who provides one-on-one instruction. The main problems are typing skills and spelling. At the center where I volunteered, the participants, many of them older people, knew how to navigate the cursor using the mouse. The lack of reading produces an inability to spell. Without knowledge of home row keys and other typing skills, participants may be slow in the mechanics of looking up information but in no way hindered from trying.
As an example, I tutored a middle-aged man for one year. He read very little, but knew how to use the computer. He also said he had a computer at home. When he was first placed on the computer during our session, he already knew how to connect it, turn it on, use the mouse and click on what he needed. He and others took placement tests using the computer. Granted, the adult literacy center in St. Petersburg may be more sophisticated than the one in South Carolina, but I think in 2010, not using or teaching computer use at these locations is behind the times.
My final thought is that I agree with the article’s premise that the government should regulate the dissemination of disaster materials. Many people with low-literacy get by with the help of friends and family. Some literacy programs provide instruction on life skills. Everything we read together was an opportunity to teach. If, for example, we read a story about a house fire, we were instructed to discuss actions in the event that they experienced a house fire. During hurricane season we discuss preparedness. When a major new story broadcasts, it is discussed. Many literate people will automatically check on the well-being of those in their own friends/family circle.
Concerning my research at this point in the semester:
I have learned what research is and how the proper use of rhetoric can make my arguments more convincing. I also know what I want to discuss which would concern some aspect of adult education and/or literacy. At this point I need to better formulate and explore one of the questions I am interested in answering. In addition, I should locate scholarly journals that deal with my subject matter. Thanks to our session at the library last week (and the introduction to RefWorks), this should go smoothly. The key will then be to find articles which support my stance (reading = time consuming) and will require me to relocate to a quiet area where I can concentrate and begin to build my paper.
Sunday, September 19, 2010
Weekly Writing #4
I located an interesting journal called New Directions for Adult and Continuing Education which contains scholarly articles based on one theme each quarter. Recent themes are "Racism and Higher Education", "Adult Education in Canada" and "Women and Education". I chose two samples of academic research and writing in the field of adult education, which is the field I am pursuing. The articles I selected for review focus on the adult female experience.
The first, Ties that bind: Cultural referent groups and coping strategies of adult women as learners is an article located in the journal. It discusses the concept of social capital as it pertains to today’s women, especially those furthering their education. The writing gives examples of experiences of Latina, Black, Muslim, and women from a number of other cultures. The source material for this writing comes from various journals which focus on such topics as adult development, psychology and religion.
Ties that Bind discusses social ties between women and social capital which affects progress by adult women in educational and business pursuits. As a result of the development of women in any given locale, communities can change in positive ways. This is due to the overall reach of women’s roles in society. In addition, the article illustrates types of relationships that women possess and shows that students who hold religious beliefs learn significantly from teachers who demonstrate the spirituality. While some relationships between women remain at surface level, others become deeper. The overall outcome is the uniting of women who meet while furthering their education.
According to Ties that Bind, women have a complex and multifaceted role within their families. The female is expected to tend to the emotional needs of other family members, notably so for Latinas and Black women. The report further states that impoverished families rely upon social capital to a greater extent. As cultural role expectations have changed, so have women’s desires for higher education. When female adult learners enter school, they do so with already established sense of values gathered from their growth over the years. In the educational forum, many women involved begin to depend upon each other and relate via give and take relationships that assist all involved.
Women students typically gravitate towards their counterparts in order to feel at ease in their new surroundings. They continue to build relationships, attend classes and become more familiar with each other. The students may also begin to place greater importance on female schoolmate relationships and less on other non-school female friends. Being among other women in this environment gives each the capacity to learn more.
Written in formal academic style, the report is arranged in a general-specific format. It is intended for those who teach of adults. It is useful for understanding the importance of and encouraging peer relationships and for providing deeper insight into concepts which facilitate learning in this population.
Nanton, C. R. (2009), Ties that bind: Cultural referent groups and coping strategies of adult women as learners. New Directions for Adult and Continuing Education, 2009: 13–22. doi: 10.1002/ace.330
---------------------------------------
The next article (from the same journal), Older Adult Women Learners in Transition discusses the novelty of increasing numbers of older women as students in institutions of higher learning and the implications for both students and instructors. It uses statistics from the Dept. of Labor, conversations with women over the age of fifty and scholarly findings about baby boomers and education from a variety of journals. This writing shows that number of older workers and women in the workforce is increasing because of the baby boomer generation and the fact that people in general, women specifically, are living longer. Simultaneously, the amount of younger workers is decreasing. It is the task of academic institutions to prepare and support these learners as they take on new careers.
Preconceived notions about older citizens often prevent the hiring of qualified, older female workers. The article looks at the experiences of six women between the ages of 55 and 64 and gives examples of their assessments to back its claims. One woman discusses growing up in a family where her father supported the home financially while her mother stayed at home. Her role in the family today is dissimilar to that of her mother. Another woman considers the group of women she attends school with as her “new family” (Wolf, 4). This is due to the time spent on and off campus, working on group projects and spending non-scholarly time together.
This article, like the previous one, argues the importance of social capital for women and includes quotes from the women mentioned above affirming the same. Positive aspects of female adult students are revealed including skills obtained from other aspects of life, which are brought into the classroom (Wolf, 7). Older adult women are seen as forging new ground by seeking additional educational opportunities and/or changing careers at an age forty midpoint in life.
The intended audience for the article is also teachers of adults who have a significant number of females as students. It is written in general-specific style. The most useful portion of the article includes an eleven-point bulleted list of ways that both students and instructors can work together to facilitate an enhanced learning environment.
Wolf, M. A. (2009), Older adult women learners in transition. New Directions for Adult and Continuing Education, 2009: 53–62. doi: 10.1002/ace.334
The first, Ties that bind: Cultural referent groups and coping strategies of adult women as learners is an article located in the journal. It discusses the concept of social capital as it pertains to today’s women, especially those furthering their education. The writing gives examples of experiences of Latina, Black, Muslim, and women from a number of other cultures. The source material for this writing comes from various journals which focus on such topics as adult development, psychology and religion.
Ties that Bind discusses social ties between women and social capital which affects progress by adult women in educational and business pursuits. As a result of the development of women in any given locale, communities can change in positive ways. This is due to the overall reach of women’s roles in society. In addition, the article illustrates types of relationships that women possess and shows that students who hold religious beliefs learn significantly from teachers who demonstrate the spirituality. While some relationships between women remain at surface level, others become deeper. The overall outcome is the uniting of women who meet while furthering their education.
According to Ties that Bind, women have a complex and multifaceted role within their families. The female is expected to tend to the emotional needs of other family members, notably so for Latinas and Black women. The report further states that impoverished families rely upon social capital to a greater extent. As cultural role expectations have changed, so have women’s desires for higher education. When female adult learners enter school, they do so with already established sense of values gathered from their growth over the years. In the educational forum, many women involved begin to depend upon each other and relate via give and take relationships that assist all involved.
Women students typically gravitate towards their counterparts in order to feel at ease in their new surroundings. They continue to build relationships, attend classes and become more familiar with each other. The students may also begin to place greater importance on female schoolmate relationships and less on other non-school female friends. Being among other women in this environment gives each the capacity to learn more.
Written in formal academic style, the report is arranged in a general-specific format. It is intended for those who teach of adults. It is useful for understanding the importance of and encouraging peer relationships and for providing deeper insight into concepts which facilitate learning in this population.
Nanton, C. R. (2009), Ties that bind: Cultural referent groups and coping strategies of adult women as learners. New Directions for Adult and Continuing Education, 2009: 13–22. doi: 10.1002/ace.330
---------------------------------------
The next article (from the same journal), Older Adult Women Learners in Transition discusses the novelty of increasing numbers of older women as students in institutions of higher learning and the implications for both students and instructors. It uses statistics from the Dept. of Labor, conversations with women over the age of fifty and scholarly findings about baby boomers and education from a variety of journals. This writing shows that number of older workers and women in the workforce is increasing because of the baby boomer generation and the fact that people in general, women specifically, are living longer. Simultaneously, the amount of younger workers is decreasing. It is the task of academic institutions to prepare and support these learners as they take on new careers.
Preconceived notions about older citizens often prevent the hiring of qualified, older female workers. The article looks at the experiences of six women between the ages of 55 and 64 and gives examples of their assessments to back its claims. One woman discusses growing up in a family where her father supported the home financially while her mother stayed at home. Her role in the family today is dissimilar to that of her mother. Another woman considers the group of women she attends school with as her “new family” (Wolf, 4). This is due to the time spent on and off campus, working on group projects and spending non-scholarly time together.
This article, like the previous one, argues the importance of social capital for women and includes quotes from the women mentioned above affirming the same. Positive aspects of female adult students are revealed including skills obtained from other aspects of life, which are brought into the classroom (Wolf, 7). Older adult women are seen as forging new ground by seeking additional educational opportunities and/or changing careers at an age forty midpoint in life.
The intended audience for the article is also teachers of adults who have a significant number of females as students. It is written in general-specific style. The most useful portion of the article includes an eleven-point bulleted list of ways that both students and instructors can work together to facilitate an enhanced learning environment.
Wolf, M. A. (2009), Older adult women learners in transition. New Directions for Adult and Continuing Education, 2009: 53–62. doi: 10.1002/ace.334
Sunday, September 12, 2010
Weekly Writing #3
The past week’s readings have helped me to hone in on what research is so that I will be able to contribute to my field during graduate studies. I have learned that research is a key element in human and world development. It may consist of data compiled to answer one or more questions. Research should result in a report which can include data derived from interviews, statistics, graphs, and charts. Academic writing is seen in textbooks and journals. It required for student papers in most levels beyond elementary school. There is no need for objectivity, though biases must be expressed appropriately. The tone, however, must remain professional.
One part of establishing credibility for a researcher is to present findings in a scholarly manner. Rules which make up academic writing exist to ensure that data is presented in a format acceptable to scholars. My immediate belief is that research in my chosen field of history involves either taking a fresh look at previous historical reports or examining aspects of history based on new findings. I will need to delve deeper to discover what research in history looks like.
Before reading The Craft of Research, I previously imagined that new ground was never before looked at or thought of concepts; however, I am pleased to discover that research is actually adding your voice to what has already been written (COR,16). This aspect is far more compelling and less intimidating than the pressure of being responsible for covering new ground alone. It opens the data of others up for interpretation. The possibilities for research are increased. Research can consist of covering and reviewing ideas that have been broached before, but doing so from a different angle. The discovery of new data can also be a feature of research, but according to The Craft of Research, you must have a reason why it’s relevant now (COR, 18-19).
Now is the time for me to dig deep and discover what it is I’d seriously like to learn more about. I have entertained minor queries in the past but lost interest in them with the passage of time. I may visit the library to check out topics which interest me such as African-American perspectives on various subjects or perhaps begin my search by considering the subject matter covered in journals on history. One of my favorite classes in undergrad was a course on historic preservation. In it I encountered resources for discovering about the past as it relates to various locations around the United States. My task will now be to inspire interest in subjects that fascinate me.
One part of establishing credibility for a researcher is to present findings in a scholarly manner. Rules which make up academic writing exist to ensure that data is presented in a format acceptable to scholars. My immediate belief is that research in my chosen field of history involves either taking a fresh look at previous historical reports or examining aspects of history based on new findings. I will need to delve deeper to discover what research in history looks like.
Before reading The Craft of Research, I previously imagined that new ground was never before looked at or thought of concepts; however, I am pleased to discover that research is actually adding your voice to what has already been written (COR,16). This aspect is far more compelling and less intimidating than the pressure of being responsible for covering new ground alone. It opens the data of others up for interpretation. The possibilities for research are increased. Research can consist of covering and reviewing ideas that have been broached before, but doing so from a different angle. The discovery of new data can also be a feature of research, but according to The Craft of Research, you must have a reason why it’s relevant now (COR, 18-19).
Now is the time for me to dig deep and discover what it is I’d seriously like to learn more about. I have entertained minor queries in the past but lost interest in them with the passage of time. I may visit the library to check out topics which interest me such as African-American perspectives on various subjects or perhaps begin my search by considering the subject matter covered in journals on history. One of my favorite classes in undergrad was a course on historic preservation. In it I encountered resources for discovering about the past as it relates to various locations around the United States. My task will now be to inspire interest in subjects that fascinate me.
Monday, September 6, 2010
Weekly Writing #2
In July, I sat down with Dr. Starks-Estes. I felt like I was going in for a job interview. I realize that much of my academic success will depend on how well I relate to my professors. After all, we will all need their guidance support, feedback to make it through to the end. After meeting, she shared with me, a plan to help me look forward to the end of two years time and figure out where I will be in terms of a potential career change, which is one of my goals.
The first two classes, which I am currently taking, seem ideal. I may change my mind as deadlines draw near. The first, Introduction to Graduate Studies with Dr. McCracken is proving to be helpful in teaching me the graduate-level process of research and is helping us all to prepare for what comes next. One of my biggest regrets about my period as an undergraduate student (besides the fact that I missed all the fun activities due to being so busy) is that I didn’t prepare for the end in a constructive way. To be honest, “the end” felt extremely far away from me. I could not fathom the fact that I was about to receive my BA until six months prior to graduation. I didn’t save my earlier papers, books, etc. This resulted in my having to redo an anxiety-riddled timed-writing that I purged. At the finish, I felt that I should have read more, known more, taken less down-time, etc. I won’t dwell on the regrets because it is finished.
The other class is this semester is Studies in African-American Literature. Being a History major, I received much information about AA History, but not necessarily on those who wrote stories about the experience. This class is proving to be interesting. I love the text, which was edited by the Dr. Armstrong, who is teaching the course. Talk about first hand!
In the spring, I am excited to be signed up for Composition Pedagogy, where I hope to be exposed to classroom processes. Along with that course will be Northern Irish Writers. I did a minute independent study of Irish Literature over the summer, which I enjoyed. I may continue with this course or change if another appeals. Summer 2011 will be a challenge. So far, I am planning to take three courses! One is a one-week intensive seminar called: Ethics in Public and Professional Life. When that is complete, the plan is to take Writing Labs with Dr. Gresham and Shakespeare and Performance or Rhetorical Analysis and Sexuality taught by the now-familiar Dr. McCracken.
By summer’s end, the bulk of my classes will be behind me! This is an extremely motivating factor. Then in the fall of 2011, it’s Studies in American Literature to 1860 with Dr. Hallock. We who love reading can’t get enough of literature. Finally it will be the third time taking on the challenge of this open-ended theory, Rhethoric and Technology, however, that is optional. If I can find and substitute another EN course, then I plan to.
Next will be Comprehensive Exams and/or Thesis or Project in the spring of 2012. I’m not totally clear on the timing of these last two courses. For now, I hope to use the Intro. to Grad. Studies course to improve my researching skills for the assignments in each class and for the thesis. What I am learning about rhetoric will assist me in the courses that deal with rhetoric. In order to identify professors, I will need to study the course catalog and as I’ve mentioned before, identify the classes which intrigue me. Unfortunately, I may have to limit it to those taught on the St. Petersburg campus.
The first two classes, which I am currently taking, seem ideal. I may change my mind as deadlines draw near. The first, Introduction to Graduate Studies with Dr. McCracken is proving to be helpful in teaching me the graduate-level process of research and is helping us all to prepare for what comes next. One of my biggest regrets about my period as an undergraduate student (besides the fact that I missed all the fun activities due to being so busy) is that I didn’t prepare for the end in a constructive way. To be honest, “the end” felt extremely far away from me. I could not fathom the fact that I was about to receive my BA until six months prior to graduation. I didn’t save my earlier papers, books, etc. This resulted in my having to redo an anxiety-riddled timed-writing that I purged. At the finish, I felt that I should have read more, known more, taken less down-time, etc. I won’t dwell on the regrets because it is finished.
The other class is this semester is Studies in African-American Literature. Being a History major, I received much information about AA History, but not necessarily on those who wrote stories about the experience. This class is proving to be interesting. I love the text, which was edited by the Dr. Armstrong, who is teaching the course. Talk about first hand!
In the spring, I am excited to be signed up for Composition Pedagogy, where I hope to be exposed to classroom processes. Along with that course will be Northern Irish Writers. I did a minute independent study of Irish Literature over the summer, which I enjoyed. I may continue with this course or change if another appeals. Summer 2011 will be a challenge. So far, I am planning to take three courses! One is a one-week intensive seminar called: Ethics in Public and Professional Life. When that is complete, the plan is to take Writing Labs with Dr. Gresham and Shakespeare and Performance or Rhetorical Analysis and Sexuality taught by the now-familiar Dr. McCracken.
By summer’s end, the bulk of my classes will be behind me! This is an extremely motivating factor. Then in the fall of 2011, it’s Studies in American Literature to 1860 with Dr. Hallock. We who love reading can’t get enough of literature. Finally it will be the third time taking on the challenge of this open-ended theory, Rhethoric and Technology, however, that is optional. If I can find and substitute another EN course, then I plan to.
Next will be Comprehensive Exams and/or Thesis or Project in the spring of 2012. I’m not totally clear on the timing of these last two courses. For now, I hope to use the Intro. to Grad. Studies course to improve my researching skills for the assignments in each class and for the thesis. What I am learning about rhetoric will assist me in the courses that deal with rhetoric. In order to identify professors, I will need to study the course catalog and as I’ve mentioned before, identify the classes which intrigue me. Unfortunately, I may have to limit it to those taught on the St. Petersburg campus.
Saturday, September 4, 2010
1st Night of Class (8/23/10)
As a recent graduate, I have barely gotten used to the fact that I, Angela Godwin, now possess a Bachelor’s degree, and furthermore, have entered graduate school. Prior to applying, I gave much thought to the prospect of an undertaking of this size. I made note of my strengths and the activities I enjoy. Based upon my conclusion, I decided that I would really enjoy teaching an audience that is eager to learn, which meant, in my opinion, that the group would need to be composed of teenaged honors students and adults. Given my age and the time required to become established in public school education, I decided it would be easier to enter the arena of adult education. I am entering this program with the hopes of gaining the necessary qualifications in order to do so.
In the MLA program, I hope to absorb significant information about subjects that interest me, namely history, so that I might pass this knowledge on to others. I believe that people either have to be required to know about topics or they must have a desire to know them in order to be successful. Having gathered credits for my undergraduate degree in 8-week increments, I am excited about having 16-weeks to spend on subjects that interest me. I am concerned about my own aptitude for original thoughts on topics. I am also worried that my words may not sufficiently take me where I want to go. I am hopeful that I will become inspired by my professors and fellow graduate students to think outside my own parameters. I am hopeful that this class will awaken the thoughts and questions that I quickly bury in the haste of everyday life and that I am able to use those images to create the thesis I need in order to graduate. This should, in turn, qualify me to take what I know and have learned and pass it on to fellow learners.
In the MLA program, I hope to absorb significant information about subjects that interest me, namely history, so that I might pass this knowledge on to others. I believe that people either have to be required to know about topics or they must have a desire to know them in order to be successful. Having gathered credits for my undergraduate degree in 8-week increments, I am excited about having 16-weeks to spend on subjects that interest me. I am concerned about my own aptitude for original thoughts on topics. I am also worried that my words may not sufficiently take me where I want to go. I am hopeful that I will become inspired by my professors and fellow graduate students to think outside my own parameters. I am hopeful that this class will awaken the thoughts and questions that I quickly bury in the haste of everyday life and that I am able to use those images to create the thesis I need in order to graduate. This should, in turn, qualify me to take what I know and have learned and pass it on to fellow learners.
Tuesday, August 31, 2010
Daily Writing 8/31/2010
In my writing on the first night of class, I expressed looking forward to inspiration from other students. My first experience came last night, when I was encouraged by the words of Scott, a fellow student. The premise was to write what you care about. Identification of my concerns must be weighed and evaluated for importance. One thing I care to know is how teaching for the adult level is made interesting to the students? Is it the personal touch or the depth of knowledge in an area? In my research, I am going to have to find others who have taught subjects that fascinate me, the ones I never had quite enough time to delve into, and find out what more I would like to know. Then I will attempt to teach this information to my fellow graduate students via our presentations.
This semester, my research will only touch the tip of the iceberg in comparison with what I have yet to learn. I hope to introduce as many uncovered concepts as possible. My biggest concern becomes finding viable subjects and hopefully, ones that are also interesting to others. In this Introduction to Graduate Studies class, I am worried about having enough time to give adequate attention to research. I need time to think things out and visit the library. I plan to devote much of my free time to my work. Being successful is vital because we all have a letter grade to maintain!
This semester, my research will only touch the tip of the iceberg in comparison with what I have yet to learn. I hope to introduce as many uncovered concepts as possible. My biggest concern becomes finding viable subjects and hopefully, ones that are also interesting to others. In this Introduction to Graduate Studies class, I am worried about having enough time to give adequate attention to research. I need time to think things out and visit the library. I plan to devote much of my free time to my work. Being successful is vital because we all have a letter grade to maintain!
Weekly Writing #1
Two essays are prominent in their instruction to readers about rhetoric. Both use examples by ancient and contemporary philosophers. Jason Thompson’s essay, Obama, Oprah and Yo’ Momma, explores the manner by which the Greek philosopher Aristotle defined and expanded upon the concept of persuasive rhetoric. Rhetorical Criticism, by Sonja K. Foss provides a dissection of a message as rhetoric. Both compositions possess aspects that pushed me to seek further information. By contemplating these ideas, I can begin to identify and take steps towards solving my uncertainties concerning rhetoric.
The definition of the term “rhetoric” appears simultaneously vague, yet deep. I needed to explore outside sources to explain its meaning in a way that would seem sensible. A series of YouTube™ videos were discovered, but they mostly restated the definitions in the assigned texts. Blogs and forums also exist, yet some do so for no other purpose than to investigate and judge the proper use of rhetoric by professionals in the media. These were helpful, but not what I needed. The best way for me to decipher rhetoric is going to be by recognizing what Thompson called “the three artistic ways people get persuaded” and by applying Foss’ suggestion concerning the questions of the Burke’s pentad.
Writings by Thompson and Foss lead to the awareness that the discourse exchanged with others is mostly rhetorical in nature. Foss refers to rhetoric as “an effort to persuade others”. In a negative context it can be identified by the logical fallacies it inspires. When used in a constructive manner, success can result as Thompson evidences by citing Oprah Winfrey’s protocol.
Foss’ composition dissects the definition of rhetoric. This method gives writers a model to compare to other writings. She uses terms such as, systematic analysis, symbolic acts and artifacts, which are unfamiliar but must soon assume a position in the graduate student’s vocabulary. Especially enlightening is Foss’ brief mention of the “pentad”. According to internet sources, this set of five specifications was designated by the philosopher, Kenneth Burke (b.1897 -d.1993). His proposal for identifying a piece’s “act, purpose, agent, agency and scene” as it relates to the artifact is a suitable way in which to critique rhetoric.
Thompson’s essay is an informative and amusing piece capable of educating readers stealthily. It enlightened me about the use of visual and verbal power combined with rhetoric. He cites methods used by Oprah Winfrey as examples, though Martha Stewart’s techniques also come to mind. The reputations of both women, enhanced by advanced uses of rhetoric, are so powerful, that the women are able to move products by simply declaring that the preferred items are “good”. Foss’ survey is useful by revealing our “use [of] rhetoric in a effort to persuade others [and to] encourage others to change in some way. Both works still left me with some uncertainty.
Thompson’s take on the “fallacy of ad hominem” caused me to wonder why the concept is considered to be an immoral practice. Upon further consideration, I realized that the resulting attacks on the creator of a particular artifact, such as his reference to Aristotle as “drug user”, fail to address the issue(s) at hand. Foss’ description of Burke’s pentad initially led me to believe that criticism must be scientific and non-personal. However, she specifically declares, “Objectivity and impartiality…are impossible”. Articles by Jason Thompson and Sonja K. Foss are essential for those who are expected to take the rhetorical approach to writing. It also enables writers to ask more meaningful questions about the messages that bombard us, namely, ‘What are you trying to persuade me to do?’
The definition of the term “rhetoric” appears simultaneously vague, yet deep. I needed to explore outside sources to explain its meaning in a way that would seem sensible. A series of YouTube™ videos were discovered, but they mostly restated the definitions in the assigned texts. Blogs and forums also exist, yet some do so for no other purpose than to investigate and judge the proper use of rhetoric by professionals in the media. These were helpful, but not what I needed. The best way for me to decipher rhetoric is going to be by recognizing what Thompson called “the three artistic ways people get persuaded” and by applying Foss’ suggestion concerning the questions of the Burke’s pentad.
Writings by Thompson and Foss lead to the awareness that the discourse exchanged with others is mostly rhetorical in nature. Foss refers to rhetoric as “an effort to persuade others”. In a negative context it can be identified by the logical fallacies it inspires. When used in a constructive manner, success can result as Thompson evidences by citing Oprah Winfrey’s protocol.
Foss’ composition dissects the definition of rhetoric. This method gives writers a model to compare to other writings. She uses terms such as, systematic analysis, symbolic acts and artifacts, which are unfamiliar but must soon assume a position in the graduate student’s vocabulary. Especially enlightening is Foss’ brief mention of the “pentad”. According to internet sources, this set of five specifications was designated by the philosopher, Kenneth Burke (b.1897 -d.1993). His proposal for identifying a piece’s “act, purpose, agent, agency and scene” as it relates to the artifact is a suitable way in which to critique rhetoric.
Thompson’s essay is an informative and amusing piece capable of educating readers stealthily. It enlightened me about the use of visual and verbal power combined with rhetoric. He cites methods used by Oprah Winfrey as examples, though Martha Stewart’s techniques also come to mind. The reputations of both women, enhanced by advanced uses of rhetoric, are so powerful, that the women are able to move products by simply declaring that the preferred items are “good”. Foss’ survey is useful by revealing our “use [of] rhetoric in a effort to persuade others [and to] encourage others to change in some way. Both works still left me with some uncertainty.
Thompson’s take on the “fallacy of ad hominem” caused me to wonder why the concept is considered to be an immoral practice. Upon further consideration, I realized that the resulting attacks on the creator of a particular artifact, such as his reference to Aristotle as “drug user”, fail to address the issue(s) at hand. Foss’ description of Burke’s pentad initially led me to believe that criticism must be scientific and non-personal. However, she specifically declares, “Objectivity and impartiality…are impossible”. Articles by Jason Thompson and Sonja K. Foss are essential for those who are expected to take the rhetorical approach to writing. It also enables writers to ask more meaningful questions about the messages that bombard us, namely, ‘What are you trying to persuade me to do?’
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)