Tuesday, August 31, 2010

Weekly Writing #1

Two essays are prominent in their instruction to readers about rhetoric. Both use examples by ancient and contemporary philosophers. Jason Thompson’s essay, Obama, Oprah and Yo’ Momma, explores the manner by which the Greek philosopher Aristotle defined and expanded upon the concept of persuasive rhetoric. Rhetorical Criticism, by Sonja K. Foss provides a dissection of a message as rhetoric. Both compositions possess aspects that pushed me to seek further information. By contemplating these ideas, I can begin to identify and take steps towards solving my uncertainties concerning rhetoric.

The definition of the term “rhetoric” appears simultaneously vague, yet deep. I needed to explore outside sources to explain its meaning in a way that would seem sensible. A series of YouTube™ videos were discovered, but they mostly restated the definitions in the assigned texts. Blogs and forums also exist, yet some do so for no other purpose than to investigate and judge the proper use of rhetoric by professionals in the media. These were helpful, but not what I needed. The best way for me to decipher rhetoric is going to be by recognizing what Thompson called “the three artistic ways people get persuaded” and by applying Foss’ suggestion concerning the questions of the Burke’s pentad.


Writings by Thompson and Foss lead to the awareness that the discourse exchanged with others is mostly rhetorical in nature. Foss refers to rhetoric as “an effort to persuade others”. In a negative context it can be identified by the logical fallacies it inspires. When used in a constructive manner, success can result as Thompson evidences by citing Oprah Winfrey’s protocol.


Foss’ composition dissects the definition of rhetoric. This method gives writers a model to compare to other writings. She uses terms such as, systematic analysis, symbolic acts and artifacts, which are unfamiliar but must soon assume a position in the graduate student’s vocabulary. Especially enlightening is Foss’ brief mention of the “pentad”. According to internet sources, this set of five specifications was designated by the philosopher, Kenneth Burke (b.1897 -d.1993). His proposal for identifying a piece’s “act, purpose, agent, agency and scene” as it relates to the artifact is a suitable way in which to critique rhetoric.


Thompson’s essay is an informative and amusing piece capable of educating readers stealthily. It enlightened me about the use of visual and verbal power combined with rhetoric. He cites methods used by Oprah Winfrey as examples, though Martha Stewart’s techniques also come to mind. The reputations of both women, enhanced by advanced uses of rhetoric, are so powerful, that the women are able to move products by simply declaring that the preferred items are “good”. Foss’ survey is useful by revealing our “use [of] rhetoric in a effort to persuade others [and to] encourage others to change in some way. Both works still left me with some uncertainty.


Thompson’s take on the “fallacy of ad hominem” caused me to wonder why the concept is considered to be an immoral practice. Upon further consideration, I realized that the resulting attacks on the creator of a particular artifact, such as his reference to Aristotle as “drug user”, fail to address the issue(s) at hand. Foss’ description of Burke’s pentad initially led me to believe that criticism must be scientific and non-personal. However, she specifically declares, “Objectivity and impartiality…are impossible”. Articles by Jason Thompson and Sonja K. Foss are essential for those who are expected to take the rhetorical approach to writing. It also enables writers to ask more meaningful questions about the messages that bombard us, namely, ‘What are you trying to persuade me to do?’

No comments:

Post a Comment