Sunday, September 19, 2010

Weekly Writing #4

I located an interesting journal called New Directions for Adult and Continuing Education which contains scholarly articles based on one theme each quarter. Recent themes are "Racism and Higher Education", "Adult Education in Canada" and "Women and Education". I chose two samples of academic research and writing in the field of adult education, which is the field I am pursuing. The articles I selected for review focus on the adult female experience.

The first, Ties that bind: Cultural referent groups and coping strategies of adult women as learners is an article located in the journal. It discusses the concept of social capital as it pertains to today’s women, especially those furthering their education. The writing gives examples of experiences of Latina, Black, Muslim, and women from a number of other cultures. The source material for this writing comes from various journals which focus on such topics as adult development, psychology and religion.

Ties that Bind discusses social ties between women and social capital which affects progress by adult women in educational and business pursuits. As a result of the development of women in any given locale, communities can change in positive ways. This is due to the overall reach of women’s roles in society. In addition, the article illustrates types of relationships that women possess and shows that students who hold religious beliefs learn significantly from teachers who demonstrate the spirituality. While some relationships between women remain at surface level, others become deeper. The overall outcome is the uniting of women who meet while furthering their education.

According to Ties that Bind, women have a complex and multifaceted role within their families. The female is expected to tend to the emotional needs of other family members, notably so for Latinas and Black women. The report further states that impoverished families rely upon social capital to a greater extent. As cultural role expectations have changed, so have women’s desires for higher education. When female adult learners enter school, they do so with already established sense of values gathered from their growth over the years. In the educational forum, many women involved begin to depend upon each other and relate via give and take relationships that assist all involved.

Women students typically gravitate towards their counterparts in order to feel at ease in their new surroundings. They continue to build relationships, attend classes and become more familiar with each other. The students may also begin to place greater importance on female schoolmate relationships and less on other non-school female friends. Being among other women in this environment gives each the capacity to learn more.

Written in formal academic style, the report is arranged in a general-specific format. It is intended for those who teach of adults. It is useful for understanding the importance of and encouraging peer relationships and for providing deeper insight into concepts which facilitate learning in this population.

Nanton, C. R. (2009), Ties that bind: Cultural referent groups and coping strategies of adult women as learners. New Directions for Adult and Continuing Education, 2009: 13–22. doi: 10.1002/ace.330

---------------------------------------
 
The next article (from the same journal), Older Adult Women Learners in Transition discusses the novelty of increasing numbers of older women as students in institutions of higher learning and the implications for both students and instructors. It uses statistics from the Dept. of Labor, conversations with women over the age of fifty and scholarly findings about baby boomers and education from a variety of journals. This writing shows that number of older workers and women in the workforce is increasing because of the baby boomer generation and the fact that people in general, women specifically, are living longer. Simultaneously, the amount of younger workers is decreasing. It is the task of academic institutions to prepare and support these learners as they take on new careers.

Preconceived notions about older citizens often prevent the hiring of qualified, older female workers. The article looks at the experiences of six women between the ages of 55 and 64 and gives examples of their assessments to back its claims. One woman discusses growing up in a family where her father supported the home financially while her mother stayed at home. Her role in the family today is dissimilar to that of her mother. Another woman considers the group of women she attends school with as her “new family” (Wolf, 4). This is due to the time spent on and off campus, working on group projects and spending non-scholarly time together.

This article, like the previous one, argues the importance of social capital for women and includes quotes from the women mentioned above affirming the same. Positive aspects of female adult students are revealed including skills obtained from other aspects of life, which are brought into the classroom (Wolf, 7). Older adult women are seen as forging new ground by seeking additional educational opportunities and/or changing careers at an age forty midpoint in life.

The intended audience for the article is also teachers of adults who have a significant number of females as students. It is written in general-specific style. The most useful portion of the article includes an eleven-point bulleted list of ways that both students and instructors can work together to facilitate an enhanced learning environment.

Wolf, M. A. (2009), Older adult women learners in transition. New Directions for Adult and Continuing Education, 2009: 53–62. doi: 10.1002/ace.334

3 comments:

  1. I liked your descriptions. The articles sound like they are very interesting. I have always been interested in these kinds of subjects. One of my high school teachers was obsessed with rhetoric so I had to find a genre that I liked to analyze. Women’s studies papers always have either the best or worst rhetoricians. Either way, it makes them fun to read. I think that your writing style will work well as a historian. You have a tone in your descriptions that denotes authority. Simply put, when people read your writing they will believe what you say. The only thing I would work on (and I’m sure you already do this in more formal formats so forgive the critique) is identifying sources in mid sentence. For example: The author explains how Cicero’s trial of Crassus had major effects on the republic. Rather than: Cicero’s trial of Crassus had major effects on the republic. But that is something small that really only matters in final projects and books. Keep up the good work.
    Also, if you are interested in reading more about women's social networks. I highly recomend Susan Ware's Women in the New Deal. It talks about how this first generation of female polititios in America contributed to the New Deal. Its relativly short and interesting. Plus it could be a source in one of the inevidible WW2 classes we have to take at this school.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Wow...really interesting the statement regarding women tending to place more importance on relationship developed inside the learning environment and more or less disregard those outside. I'm not sure I understand why that is...not saying I don't agree with it. Thinking of it on a simplistic level I'm guessing it is because they have more in common with them due to the hear and now; what is in front of me is the most importaant. That is really and interesting concept...

    ReplyDelete
  3. Thanks Jan. I think it does have to do with the commonalities.

    Preston, thank you also. You are absolutely correct. When I read alot, I need to improve on reflecting the intellectual property of the author and not just jump straight into synthesis. In fact, I see sentences above where I should have done just that. I also appreciate the reading suggestion. Thanks again!

    ~Angela

    ReplyDelete