Thursday, October 14, 2010

Weekly Writing #7

Weekly Writing #7
Asking the Right Questions: Ch 13 & 14

     Chapter 13 discusses strengthening arguments by excluding questions which form dichotomies. It provides good examples on accomplishing this. Also explained is the practicality of using If-clauses. Chapter 13 was confusing to me until I drew a line through extraneous words. Then I reread only the words which mattered and understood better. I initially thought the chapter asked us not to limit conclusion in our papers, but this made no sense. Papers should have a strong final conclusion. I discovered that what it actually does is ask writers to explore several conclusions during the research process and pick the best one. This advice: “One clever way to weaken strong reasoning is the make the claim that experts disagree” (163) is useful. It addresses a problem that I expect, though I have not yet discovered it as I am not very far along into my writing.

    While reading Chapter 13, I scrutinized my own research question. The original question I planned to answer is: “What is the propensity for students from an ABE background to successfully complete post-secondary education degrees?” If I stick with this query, my paper will simply inform but will not be very compelling. The examples in the text seem to pertain best to controversial questions. I discovered that my question is not controversial enough.
   
     Based upon the original question, I can ask: “Is there more than one possible answer?” The answer is no. My original question only allows for a dichotomy. Browne & Keeley advise the use of “why, when & where” questions to help writers discover more conclusions. On that note, I can ask: How many students from ABE backgrounds go on to attend and graduate from college?” Then I can ask “Why is the amount of students the number that it is?” “When did the number of students increase or decrease?” and “Where are the regions that send ABE graduates to college?” These are just possible examples of how I can (and may) expand my original question. I can look for patterns in the answers.

     Another word of instruction in chapter 13 is when your question ceases to be a dichotomy, work on finding a variety of possible answers. Next look at the answers derived from the revised question and accept the one that is sensible to you. In the event that you acquire some or most but not all the data you can, use the “if-clause” (if/then) to show the audience that you possess only limited knowledge of the subject. I think this shows honesty and enhances the writer’s credibility. There may be more data out there.

     If I ask: “How many students from ABE backgrounds go on to attend and graduate from college?” and in the resulting research I find that the number of students who do so is insignificant, I can again revise my research question and change it to: “How can students from an ABE background successfully complete a post-secondary education degree?” Then I can research not only the propensity but the challenges and propose solutions to increase the number of students. This would be more interesting and has the potential to positively contribute to my field.
  • If I found that:
    • The number of students who go on to college is low
      • I could ask:
        • What can be done to increase the number
    • The number is average
        • What can be done to increase the number
    • The number is high
        • What is the reason for this success
        • Is there something to be learned that can be applied towards traditional or non-traditional students
Chapter 13 revealed a practical way to make my output stronger!

   Although I have experience as an individual who attended high school for twelve years but failed to graduate (fell short .5 credits due to pregnancy) but obtained a GED two years later and who did not go to college directly following high school, Chapter 14 states that I should not rely on my personal experience as the basis for my conclusion. The authors of Asking the Right Questions state, “Because we wish certain conclusions to be true, we may reason as if they are true, despite strong evidence to the contrary” (Browne & Keeley, 169). In relation to my own research, I may wish to instill hope by suggesting that non-traditional college students succeed in college, when the fact of the matter may turn out to be that they do not. I must be careful not to project my own desires onto my project.

     The danger of stereotyping is mentioned. Many who attend ABE classes are wrongly categorized. I would like to contribute by adding to the work that wipes out such assumptions. However, I too would be guilty of stereotyping if I approach the subject in a way that supposes that there is truth to such statements. Also discussed is to “never permit ourselves to be so sure of anything that we stop searching for an improved version” (Browne & Keeley, 172). I do not know yet what my research may turn up; whether it is good or bad news from my perspective. This goes along with the earlier class discussion on changing ones mind after discovering that one’s argument has been disproved during research. These two chapters warn us to be responsible researching beginning with the very questions we ask. It is possible that if we enter into a project with our minds made up, we could very well find the answers we have already predetermined in our minds. This would be irresponsible and untrue to our chosen fields.

1 comment:

  1. I really like the way you revamped your research questions. I wouldn’t be surprised if you end up answering both questions since educational success rates are different everywhere. Also, I think your perspective and experience in adult education is very valuable. Especially if you have been trained to do it and have been helping adults get their GED. Well, here is the lady I was telling you about in class that can help with your paper. I am not sure if you are supposed to be a Sarasota student for her to help, but if you don’t mention it I don’t think she will.

    Valerie Lipscomb, Ph.D.
    Writing Resource Center Director
    University of South Florida Sarasota-Manatee
    8350 N. Tamiami Trail, C263
    Sarasota, FL 34243
    (941) 359-4718 (campus)
    lipscomb@sar.usf.edu

    ReplyDelete